A great frankfurter is all about balance – the snap of the sausage, the softness of the bun, and, of course, the toppings. But why settle for the usual mustard and ketchup when you can explore the world of frankfurter toppings? Here’s our guide to some of the best regional and quirky ways to top your Yorkshire Frankfurters – whether you want to go classic, bold, or completely unexpected.
The classic hot dog cart favourite:
✅ Sauerkraut
✅ Spicy brown mustard
Simple, punchy, and a favourite on the bustling streets of NYC. The tang of the sauerkraut cuts through the richness of the frankfurter, while the mustard adds just enough heat.
A tribute to our own backyard:
✅ Wensleydale cheese crumbles
✅ Henderson’s Relish onions
✅ A drizzle of wholegrain mustard
Henderson’s Relish gives this hot dog a proper Sheffield kick, while the Wensleydale adds a bit of creamy sharpness.
A nod to the birthplace of the frankfurter:
✅ Currywurst sauce (a mix of ketchup, curry powder & Worcestershire sauce)
✅ Crispy fried onions
Think of it as the best of a Berlin street market in a bun – rich, tangy, and with just the right amount of spice.
For those who like a little heat:
✅ Smashed avocado
✅ Jalapeño slices
✅ Chipotle mayo
Smoky, creamy, and with a fiery kick – a proper upgrade for anyone who thinks a frankfurter should bite back.
East meets West in the most unexpected way:
✅ Teriyaki glaze
✅ Pickled ginger
✅ Sesame seeds
A beautiful umami-packed combination that’s salty, sweet, and slightly tangy.
A Parisian-style hot dog with a fancy twist:
✅ Melted raclette cheese
✅ Dijon mustard
✅ Caramelised onions
It’s basically French onion soup on a frankfurter – rich, gooey, and seriously indulgent.
A lighter, Nordic-inspired topping:
✅ Dill & mustard sauce
✅ Pickled cucumber
✅ Crushed rye crackers
A fresh and slightly tangy take, with a bit of crunch from the rye.
Big, bold, and messy in the best way:
✅ Pulled pork
✅ BBQ sauce
✅ Pickles
A true two-hander of a hot dog. If you like BBQ, this one’s for you.
Mediterranean flair meets meaty goodness:
✅ Sun-dried tomato pesto
✅ Shaved parmesan
✅ Rocket leaves
Think of it as the poshest hot dog at the party – fresh, herby, and full of flavour.
The hot dog for breakfast lovers:
✅ A fried egg
✅ Crispy bacon bits
✅ Brown sauce
If you believe breakfast should be an all-day thing, this is your perfect frankfurter.
There’s no wrong way to top a Yorkshire Frankfurter, but why not get adventurous? Whether you go for a classic like sauerkraut and mustard or a wildcard like Wensleydale cheese and Henderson’s Relish, the most important thing is to enjoy it.
What’s your go-to frankfurter topping? Let us know – or better yet, grab some of our Yorkshire Frankfurters and try them all!
Order Your Yorkshire Frankfurters Here
Celebrating Heritage, Sustainability, and Taste
Order online from our selection of locally-sourced, high-quality Yorkshire native breed meat and charcuterie, plus our range of carefully curated artisan food products, including cheeses, jams, and preserves.
We’re proud to support FareShare Yorkshire.
